Reply to topic  [ 52 posts ]  Go to page Previous  1, 2, 3, 4
The Ultimate Album Ranking Thread 
Author Message
contact admin for a custom title
contact admin for a custom title
User avatar

Joined: Thu Feb 16, 2006 9:05 pm
Posts: 1845
Location: New York
Post Re: The Ultimate Album Ranking Thread
I'd say This is my Fashion (Passion?), Foreigner, and Kiss Me Baby are the only ones I don't love, but they're still good.

Edit: No one mentioned "You Are", such a great track :shred:

_________________
I wonder if I am sick
So this door will never break
I need to know more about my space
It's Penalty Life


Sun May 28, 2017 6:06 pm
Profile
premium buster
premium buster
User avatar

Joined: Mon Mar 16, 2009 12:11 am
Posts: 1382
Location: Indiana
Post Re: The Ultimate Album Ranking Thread
[quote="MyFoot"]Foreigner[/quote]
[quote="MyFoot"]don't love[/quote]

:hmph:

_________________
[quote="GoldenRhino"]"...don't give a fuck."
[i]- Sawao Yamanaka, 2010.
[/i][/quote]


Sun May 28, 2017 6:45 pm
Profile
moderator
moderator
User avatar

Joined: Mon Mar 14, 2005 3:28 pm
Posts: 12301
Location: Lost Angels
Post Re: The Ultimate Album Ranking Thread
The Ultimate Friendship Killing Thread

_________________
I'm animal


Sun May 28, 2017 7:09 pm
Profile WWW
contact admin for a custom title
contact admin for a custom title
User avatar

Joined: Thu Feb 16, 2006 9:05 pm
Posts: 1845
Location: New York
Post Re: The Ultimate Album Ranking Thread
[quote="Spike"][quote="MyFoot"]Foreigner[/quote]
[quote="MyFoot"]don't love[/quote]

:hmph:[/quote]

Great chorus :groovin:

_________________
I wonder if I am sick
So this door will never break
I need to know more about my space
It's Penalty Life


Sun May 28, 2017 8:50 pm
Profile
vain dog
vain dog

Joined: Sat Oct 10, 2015 10:24 am
Posts: 463
Post Re: The Ultimate Album Ranking Thread
[quote="MyFoot"]No one mentioned "You Are", such a great track :shred:[/quote]
Indeed, it's one of my favourite 1st Movement tracks. I might prefer the live version from [i]REVIVAL OF MOTION PICTURES[/i] over the album version.


Mon May 29, 2017 2:33 am
Profile
premium buster
premium buster
User avatar

Joined: Mon Jun 13, 2005 11:23 pm
Posts: 1221
Post Re: The Ultimate Album Ranking Thread
[quote="Ashinow"]

[b]Scarecrow[/b] is an emotional rollercoaster. ‘More than God, I believe in you’. I had teenage angst, an existential crisis. My demeanour was gloomy. The pillows, and in particularly Sawao’s singing was so powerful, emotionally, it transcends language. His singing was the language of emotion. This song alone, stands for a memory of my college (bachelor) years. I was lonely? Maybe. I felt disconnected? Hell yes. One time I was walking in the university building thinking ‘Why am I still alive’, shouldn’t I have died already? I was not REALLY depressed, or so I had myself believed, no, I could not connect to other people on a deeper level. I was always walking around with my headphones around my neck.. and in those days at least 80% of it was the pillows. How many times have I listened to this song, ‘Scarecrow’? It is like an soundtrack of those days. You can hear Sawao basically wailing, pouring his heart out, this is how I felt, I think… but I never let it out.. just kept it inside me… just like the music. Pirouzu.net/forum was a ‘God-given’. I could connect with people on such a deep level… sometimes I felt more at ease communicating/reading the board than talking with friends. Scarecrow even inspired me to a poem


Fastforward to Tokyo 2014: the pillows 25th anniversary concert. First song they played: Bloody Fucking Scarecrow. Can you believe it? I almost cried, man…. Even as I am writing this, it’s all coming back… I couldn’t look to the stage… see Sawao singing.. if I did, I would have burst out in tears…. I had a lump in my throat during the whole song… Scarecrow..
You know.. if this song would be on Happy Bivouac.. then that would raise the album some places higher.. but it happened to be on Wake Up!x3.
And if you look up the lyrics… it was exactly how I felt.. even without really knowing the literally translation, I felt it.
You know… if Scarecrow is kinda gloomy.. the rest of the album really has a happy-go-lucky attitude to it. It has quite a light attitude. And though, I painted quite a black picture just above, in reality I am quite a laid-back person…. [b]Boat House[/b] is such a song. Images of me biking to and fro school in the summer wind, humming, whistling, or singing aloud to this song come to mind. I wouldn’t listen to the pillows if they had only sad, serious songs, no. Indeed, the songs are day-to-day songs that function as lift-boosters to me. And then, if I compare Happy Bivouac to WUx3, I think HB generally sounds harsher to me… I could do with less distortion, less exuberance… but the guitar tone on WUx3 just clicks… and the guitar solos are just as great/effective.
<SNIP>
[/quote]

Thanks for posting this man. It was a really good read and I can see how important that album is to you. Scarecrow is a favorite song of mine too; it's one if the few singles I physically own and one of the very few songs that I've basically memorized the lyrics to. Your post was kind of what I was hoping to get out of this thread; personal stories relating why the albums we love so much are our favorites. And I totally agree with you here:

[quote]So I think, that the first introduction to the pillows is what got you into the music, and the associations you make with these songs are so powerful, this alone counts for a great deal the personal preferences of our Busters.[/quote]

For me, it was taken a step further. I think I mentioned this when we made that video message to the band, but the pillows basically shaped my musical tastes. I never really LIKED music until I heard that distinctive style on HB and RH, and I've always tried to find bands that share those same qualities. Of course, there's stuff I heard later that I like better than some of the FLCL stuff (i.e., Strange Chameleon is a top 10 track no doubt, and I didn't hear that song until about a year or two after I got into the pillows). But I think your point still stands. Thanks again for sharing all that.

As for Moon Gold...

[quote]I by no means dislike Moon Gold, but I do find that tonally it's the least up my alley - both because of the vocals and because of the guitar/drum sounds. I throw it on once in a while, and thoroughly enjoy it every time, but [b]I am much more drawn towards pounding rhythms and wailing/crunchy/distorted guitars. More Century Creepers and less Yume no you na yakusoku[/b][/quote]

Yes! This, exactly this, especially the bolded. Century Creepers is a song I love and is very indicative of the pounding rhythms and crunchy guitar sound that the pillows have mastered. That's why i'd still even rank albums like Pied Piper and Trial over Moon Gold; I dig that style more.

If I'm in a lighter mood, like after listening to a lot of Beatles stuff for instance, I'll throw on Moon Gold. I do love Kiss Me Baby and Kimi ga Iru. But I find the album itself to plod around a bit too much. That's why i was really grateful for the 1st Movement show DVD. That version of Sayonara Third Planet was absolutely beautiful, and Razorlike Blue was totally badass. The band brings that tone that they have now mastered, and make the songs from the 1st Movement sound way better, to my ears at least. If the pillows were to do another cover album for their 30th anniversary, I would hope that it'd be from mainly the 1st Movement. I for one would love to hear an updated version of Kiss Me Baby and If You Sing in the Rain. But for now, my go to versions of of Moon Gold songs are either on Turn Back or on the 1st Movement Show DVD.



...OK, but the original Kiss Me Baby does totally rock, I'll admit that. :shred:


Mon May 29, 2017 11:04 pm
Profile
Rocktransformed
Rocktransformed
User avatar

Joined: Tue Nov 15, 2005 8:44 am
Posts: 1925
Location: Atlanta
Post Re: The Ultimate Album Ranking Thread
Top tier:

1. Little Busters
2. White Incarnation
3. Please Mr. Lostman
4. Happy Bivouac
5. Smile

White Incarnation and Smile are albums I absolutely love that probably wouldn't make anyone else's top 5, but they're very dear to me and I come back to them more often than some other, more beloved albums.

Runners Up:

6. Runners High
7. My Foot
8. Living Field
9. Thank You My Twilight
10. Good Dreams

These are all great albums, but I don't listen to them quite as much. Actually, My Foot is one of my top 5 go-to Pillows albums these days, but objectively I don't like it quite as much/think it's as good as Runners High. TYMT has at least one of my top five favorite songs (Shiroi Natus etc.) but I still feel it's an inconsistent record and Manabe's crummy guitar tone always bothers me. I quite like Good Dreams after not being crazy about it initially outside of Sono Mirai, and not listening to it much for years and years. It's a consistently solid album and right after My Foot for best post-TYMT album.

Good, but less listened:

11. Kool Spice
12. Trial
13. Moon Gold
14. Penalty Life
15. Stroll And Roll

Each of these albums has some songs that I really like, but not as many as the above. Or, I just don't quite like them as much.

The stuff I don't like/never listen to, outside of 2-3 songs per album (at most):

Moondust
Pied Piper
Wake Up! x 3
Horn Again
OOPARTS

Still haven't listened to Nook In The Brain yet. Probably will tomorrow.

Not sure how to rank others. I listen to Turn Back a lot and think it's great. Ditto for Bootleg The Pillows. Rarely listen to the first two mini-albums, but they have good stuff on them.

_________________
[quote="Spike"]I'm wisely spending my time posting on an internet message board for a Japanese rock band that I heard in an anime show I watched a decade ago.[/quote]
[url=http://www.last.fm/user/SinkingStarship]My Last.fm Profile[/url]


Tue Aug 15, 2017 11:20 pm
Profile
Display posts from previous:  Sort by  
Reply to topic   [ 52 posts ]  Go to page Previous  1, 2, 3, 4

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: Google [Bot] and 15 guests


You cannot post new topics in this forum
You cannot reply to topics in this forum
You cannot edit your posts in this forum
You cannot delete your posts in this forum
You cannot post attachments in this forum

Search for:
Jump to:  
Powered by phpBB © 2000, 2002, 2005, 2007 phpBB Group.
Designed by STSoftware for PTF.